Roadmap Goals and Progress
The Sustainable Energy Roadmap team has worked in close coordination with the City of Fresno to develop a customized policy roadmap containing guidance on how to transform the local new energy economy. Each recommended roadmap goal is supported with relevant case studies, reports, and templates to support local and regional implementation efforts.
ENERGY & WATER EFFICIENCY
|Doing more with less energy means cost savings, increased comfort, and a more secure electricity grid. Energy efficiency is the most cost-effective strategy for commercial building owners to reduce energy usage and associated operating expenses, while also increasing occupant comfort and employee productivity. When combined with on-site renewable energy generation, demand side management, and energy storage, commercial buildings can achieve deep reductions in grid energy usage.|
4 of 7 Goals In Progress
3 of 7 Goals Achieved
[POL1] Set an energy efficiency target for existing municipal buildings and create an energy reduction plan to achieve goal.
The City has not set an energy efficiency target specifically for municipal buildings, but has set a target for City operations.
Chapter 7 of the 2014 Fresno General Plan states for Fresno to increase use of renewable energy to meet 50% of annual electrical consumption for City operations and reduce the City's peak electrical load by 10% through energy efficiency/conversation.
[POL2] Establish energy- and water-efficient product procurement requirements for municipal agencies.
Has not adopted an environmentally preferred product procurement policy.
Convene a working group to update procurement policies and guidelines to specify energy and water efficiency as a criteria in city/ county purchasing decisions. Policies can specify the required use of "ENERGY STAR" or "WaterSense" certified products, including appliances or fixtures, or similar product efficiency standards.
[POL3] Adopt a temperature policy for municipal buildings with programmable thermostats.
Has not adopted a temperature policy for municipal buildings.
Adopt a temperature policy that establishes standardized indoor temperature setpoints for municipal facilities that vary with the season, occupancy hours, and type of facility, and designates exclusions for select building uses. Temperature set points can draw upon precedents set by local colleges and universities, ASHRAE Standard 55 (Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy), climate zones, or comparable guidelines.
[POL4] Adopt ordinance requiring non-residential building energy benchmarking & public disclosure that is in compliance with AB 1103.
There is no ordinance requiring non-residential building energy benchmarking and public disclosure that is compliance with AB 1103. According to the General Plan, the city will promote the Energy Use Disclosure.
Establish a policy or ordinance that is in compliance with California's AB1103, which requires energy benchmarking and public disclosure for non-residential properties. Consider the phased implementation schedule regarding a building's square footage, as well as other factors such as frequency of reporting to governing municipality.
[POL5] Adopt a residential and/or commercial energy conservation ordinance.
There is no energy conservation ordinance for residential or commercial, but the city has the Home Energy Tune (HETU) and BETU Programs. City of Fresno implemented the Fresno Energy Watch Program as part of the Fresno Small Business Energy Makeover.
Establish a RECO and/or CECO that requires property owners to ensure that their properties meet municipally-determined energy and water efficiency standards before they may be sold, renovated, or receive a rental license.
[POL6] Set water conservation target for municipal operations that exceeds state reduction goals.
Has set water conservation target for municipal operations that exceeds state reduction goals.
City of Fresno has dropped water demand to less than 240 gallons per person per day. "20 Gallon Challenge" http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/PublicUtilities/Watermanagement/Conservation/default.htm
[POL7] Adopt a community-wide water conservation ordinance that meets/exceeds state reduction goals.
Has adopted a community-wide water conservation ordinance to comply with state reduction goals.
Water Schedule, City of Fresno Stage 2 Water Shortage Contingency Plan: http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/PublicUtilities/Watermanagement/Conservation/Schedule.htm
2 of 2 Goals Achieved
[P1] Implement expedited permitting measures for qualifying energy efficiency upgrades.
Has implemented expedited permitting measures for qualifying energy efficiency upgrades.
Expedited processing can be achieved if project qualifies under the Fresno Green Program: http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/DARM/DevelopmentServices/StandardsGuidelines/Fresno+Green.htm
[P2] Reduce or eliminate permitting fees for high-efficiency equipment upgrades.
Has reduced or eliminated permitting fees for high-efficiency equipment upgrades.
A 25% fee reduction can be achieved if project qualifies under the Fresno Green Program: http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/DARM/DevelopmentServices/StandardsGuidelines/Fresno+Green.htm
Planning & Zoning
4 of 7 Goals In Progress
3 of 7 Goals Achieved
[Z1] Adopt a green building code with energy efficiency standards that exceed California Title 24 requirements.
Has adopted a building code with efficiency standards that exceed California Title 24 reqs
The Fresno Green Program provides a green building code with some areas exceeding Title 24 requirements. http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/DARM/DevelopmentServices/StandardsGuidelines/Fresno+Green.htm
[Z2] Add an energy element or sustainability element to the municipal general plan.
Has added an energy element or sustainability element to the municipal general plan.
General Plan sustainability element can be found in Chapter 7: Resource Conservation and Resilience.
[Z3] Encourage use of cool roof materials and green roofs during roof upgrade projects.
Does not address the use of cool roof materials and green roofs during roof upgrade projects.
Adopt an ordinance that requires energy-conserving cool roofs on qualifying buildings, such as new and replacement low-sloped roofs. Specify minimum initial reflectance and initial thermal emittance values.
[Z4] Implement a LED street lighting retrofit program.
Has not implemented an LED street lighting retrofit program.
Convene a working group to plan and implement a LED upgrade program for street lighting and exterior building lighting, in order to reduce energy and maintenance costs and minimize the environmental impact. A retrofit program may be financed through an energy savings performance contract, a green revolving fund, or any other number of ways.
[Z5] Provide guidance for energy efficiency upgrades in historic buildings.
Does not provide guidance for energy efficiency upgrades in historic buildings.
Develop guidelines and special plan review processes for energy efficiency upgrades in historic buildings that protect property owners' ability to improve their building's energy performance. Allow staff member to review and approve permit applications when possible rather than requiring a committee or planning commission review.
[Z6] Amend residential and commercial building codes to include water efficiency standards.
According to the General Plan, a 10 to 20 percent reduction in water use in most new construction will occur.
Update local building code to incorporate water-efficiency requirements for new residential and/or commercial construction and renovations. This can include the use of low-flow toilets, showerheads, and efficient irrigation technologies on residential or commercial properties in retrofit projects or before sale.
[Z7] Explore adoption of a graywater ordinance.
Has explored adoption of a graywater ordinance.
City of Fresno plans to peruse the development of a recycled water system, stated in the General plan Chapter 6: Public Utilities and Services.
1 of 7 Goals In Progress
6 of 7 Goals Achieved
[F1] Publicize available rebates and incentives for energy efficiency upgrades for residents and businesses.
Publicizes available rebates and incentives for efficiency upgrades to community.
Energy rebates and incentives are publicized to participants of the HETU and BETU Programs. Rebates can also be found in the Fresno Energy Watch, Energy Watch, and PG&E: http://fresnoenergywatch.com/find-rebates/
[F2] Publicize available incentives and financing for energy efficiency upgrades to public agencies.
Publicizes available incentives & financing for efficiency upgrades to public agencies.
Incentives and financing options are publicized via the Central Valley Energy Tune-Up, Fresno Energy Watch and BETU Program
[F3] Ensure energy and water efficiency upgrades are eligible in local Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) program.
Energy and water efficiency upgrades are eligible in local PACE program.
Eligible thanks to the Central Valley Energy Tune-Up, Fresno Energy Watch and BETU Program
[F4] Explore creation of revolving loan fund for municipal energy upgrades.
Has not explored creation of revolving loan fund for municipal energy upgrades.
Establish a working group to explore the feasibility of establishing a local green revolving fund to provide a sustainable funding cycle for municipal lighting upgrades and other clean energy projects using the many successful examples from across the country. Identify sources of capital and steps to implementation.
[F5] Publicize existing financing programs and innovative financing models for energy efficiency projects.
Publicizes financing programs and innovative financing models for efficiency projects.
Publicized in the Central Valley Energy Tune-Up and Fresno Energy Watch website. Fresno Energy Watch attends conference for local businesses to promote financing, rebates and incentives for energy efficiency projects
[F6] Publicize available rebates and incentives for water efficiency upgrades and water-conserving appliances.
Publicizes incentives for water efficiency upgrades and water-conserving appliances.
Water rebates and water conserving appliances can be found on the City's website http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/PublicUtilities/Watermanagement/rebatespermits.htm
[F7] Promote water and energy efficiency incentives and financial assistance resources to local industries.
Promotes water or energy efficiency incentives and financial resources to local industries.
Financing options commercial can be found on the Central Energy Tune-Up website
2 of 6 Goals In Progress
4 of 6 Goals Achieved
[M1] Provide educational materials related to energy efficiency measures and technologies to the community.
Provides educational materials on energy efficiency resources to the community.
City of Fresno provide free energy assessments through the BETU and HETU programs to educate home and business/building owners about the inefficient areas of their house or facility.
[M2] Promote energy inefficient appliance trade-in programs to residents and businesses.
Promotes energy inefficient appliance trade-in programs to residents and businesses.
Energy programs are promoted through the BETU and HETU reports. Energy programs for business can also be found in Fresno Energy Watch website http://fresnoenergywatch.com/
[M3] Implement an energy upgrade program for residents, including low-income households, and local businesses.
Has implemented energy upgrade program for residents and local businesses.
BETU and HETU Programs, applications can be found in the Central Valley Energy Tune-Up website http://www.cvetu.com/
[M4] Provide educational materials related to water conservation and efficiency to residents and businesses.
Provides educational materials on water conservation and efficiency to residents/businesses.
City of Fresno provides various materials: http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/PublicUtilities/Watermanagement/rebatespermits.htm
[M5] Encourage agricultural industry to take advantage of water efficiency opportunities.
Does not encourage agricultural industry to take advantage of water efficiency opportunities.
Publicize available incentives for agricultural pump retrofits from state, federal, and local governments as well as the public utility. Include marketing for educational opportunities related to advanced pumping efficiency. Work with local utilities to encourage agricultural pump owners to receive and report on a subsidized pump efficiency test to become eligible for pump retrofit incentives.
[M6] Design and implement a behavior-based energy and/or water conservation program.
Has not designed and implemented a behavior-based energy or water conservation program.
Convene a working group between municipal staff, the local utility, and other relevant stakeholders to design and pilot a behavior-based energy and water efficiency program. Identify key stakeholders and community organizations who are opinion leaders in the area to identify and develop a conservation program that appeals to local core values. These could include non-profits, faith-based groups, HOAs, etc. Emphasize the voluntary nature of the program to promote energy efficiency and/or water conservation in the community.
1 of 4 Goals In Progress
3 of 4 Goals Achieved
[WFD1] Publicize energy efficiency-focused workforce trainings and professional development resources to local technicians.
Publicizes energy efficiency-focused trainings and resources to local technicians.
The Water/Energy Nexus provides pump and well efficiency workshops.
[WFD2] Partner with local industry, academic and workforce organizations to provide energy efficiency training programs.
Has partnered with local organizations to provide energy efficiency training programs.
Working with Fresno State and the Great Valley Center, the Water/Energy Nexus workshops were created. Fresno State also provides pump efficiency tests.
[WFD3] Publicize water efficiency technical trainings and resources to area residents and professionals.
Publicizes water efficiency technical training or resources to community.
City of Fresno currently provides free leak surveys and landscape consultations. http://www.fresno.gov/Government/DepartmentDirectory/PublicUtilities/Watermanagement/Conservation/Surveys.htm
[WFD4] Partner with local industry, academic and workforce organizations to provide water efficiency training programs.
Has not partnered with local industry & organizations to provide water efficiency training programs.
Provide for water efficiency professional training programs. Partner with local industry, water agency, academic and workforce development organizations to increase the rigor and visibility of these trainings. Work to establish water efficiency and management skills, such as auditing or retrofit support, as a workforce goal in the region.
RENEWABLE ENERGY & STORAGE
|Generating clean power from renewable energy sources comes with many economic and environmental benefits. Once building energy efficiency measures have been implemented, the remaining energy consumption needs can be satisfied using a portfolio of on-site renewable energy technologies, such as solar PV, solar water heating, small wind turbines, geothermal heat pumps, and bioenergy. The economic viability of renewable energy projects will depend on external factors, such as utility rate schedules and local market conditions.|
3 of 3 Goals In Progress
[POL1] Establish a renewable energy target for municipal facilities or offset a portion of municipal electricity usage with green power.
Target has not been set for municipal facilities but a target has been set to increase use of renewable energy to meet 50% of annual electrical consumption for City operations.
Convene a working group of internal stakeholders (such as public works, planning, and facilities) to explore the feasibility of setting a renewable energy target for municipal facilities, which may be specified as an installed capacity goal or a minimum share of municipal electricity usage purchased from renewable sources. Consider a policy that future facilities be designed and built to be Zero Net Energy. Renewable energy target may be stated in a climate action plan or similar document, or enacted as an ordinance.
[POL2] Explore implementation of a community choice aggregation program.
Has not explored implementation of a community choice aggregation program.
Establish a working group with neighboring local governments and other relevant stakeholders to evaluate the feasibility and benefits of establishing or joining an existing community choice aggregation to secure an alternative energy supply contract, if such arrangements are legally permitted within the state.
[POL3] Create renewable portfolio standard for municipal electric utility in line with the state requirement for investor-owned utilities.
No renewable portfolio standard currently in place for municipal electric utility.
Establish a working group to evaluate the feasibility of adopting a renewable portfolio standard (RPS) for the municipal utility that equals or exceeds the state requirement of 33% for investor-owned utilities. Consider incorporating renewable energy and energy efficiency measures and strategies into integrated resource planning efforts, or exploring renewable energy power-purchase agreements.
2 of 4 Goals In Progress
2 of 4 Goals Achieved
[P1] Adopt standardized permitting application forms for various small-scale renewable energy and energy storage systems.
Has not adopted standardized permitting application forms for small-scale renewable energy systems.
Adopt standard permit applications for each locally relevant type of small-scale renewable energy systems. Standard permit includes site plan, an electrical plan, and technology-specific specifications and regulations. Consider incorporating battery system permitting specification into solar PV system permits.
[P2] Provide an overview of the permitting and inspection process for locally relevant types of renewable energy systems.
Overview of permitting/inspection process for relevant renewable energy systems is provided on City website
[P3] Place a cap on permitting fees for residential renewable energy systems, or base fees on cost recovery.
Has not capped permitting fees or based fees on cost recovery for renewable energy systems.
Permit fees for solar photovoltaics, solar water heating systems, ground-source heat pumps, small-scale wind, and energy storage systems should be based on cost recovery or a tiered fee schedule according to system size, and subject to a reasonably determined fee cap.
[P4] Implement expedited permitting measures for qualifying systems utilizing standardized application forms.
Has adopted expedited permitting for qualifying systems using a standardized application.
Expedited permitting can be completed through Fresno Green. A project is considered a Fresno Green Project on a point basis. More info can be found here: http://www.fresno.gov/NR/rdonlyres/155DEF35-927F-4456-BAAC-B0939B5246D0/0/GreenFresno2009Handbook.pdf
Planning & Zoning
3 of 5 Goals In Progress
2 of 5 Goals Achieved
[Z1] Incorporate renewable energy goals and strategies into long-term planning documents, such as General Plans.
Has incorporated renewable energy goals and strategies into long-term planning documents.
Renewable goals can be found in the General Plan in Chapter 7: Resource Conservation and Resilience
[Z2] Encourage new construction to be built "solar ready", with pre-wiring for solar PV and easy plumbing access for solar water heating.
Measures in place to encourage new construction to be built "solar ready."
[Z3] Update zoning code to establish and expand allowed use zones for renewable energy systems.
Has not updated zoning codes to establish and expand allowed use zones for renewable energy systems.
Update zoning code to specify where renewable energy systems are considered a by-right allowed use in order to eliminate special reviews and lengthy permitting processes. Ensure that zoning and design requirements (such as setbacks, height limits, etc.) do not seriously restrict property owners' ability to install renewable energy systems, and consider widening scope to include energy storage as an eligible technology. Consider Overlay Zones for development on underutilized land, while maintaining original zoned use.
[Z4] Provide clear guidance for renewable energy system installations on historic buildings.
No clear guidance provided for renewable energy system installations on historic buildings.
Develop guidelines and special plan review processes for renewable energy installations in historic buildings that protect property owners' ability to improve their building's energy performance. Allow staff member to review and approve permit applications when possible rather than requiring a committee or planning commission review.
[Z5] Incorporate measures for electric vehicle charging stations into renewable energy planning efforts.
Has not incorporated measures for EV charging stations into renewable energy planning efforts.
Include electric vehicle considerations in renewable energy planning efforts. Potential measures include electric vehicle provisions in the next general plan update, an ordinance that requires pre-wiring for both solar and EVSE in new construction, including solar feasibility assessments in any electric vehicle readiness planning, and more.
1 of 4 Goals In Progress
3 of 4 Goals Achieved
[F1] Publicize available rebates and incentives for renewable energy and energy storage technologies to residents and businesses.
Publicizes available rebates/incentives for renewable energy to residents and businesses.
City of Fresno publicizes available rebates and incentives through the Home Energy Tune Up program and Business Energy Tune Up Program.
[F2] Publicize available incentives and financing for renewable energy and energy storage technologies to public agencies.
Does not publicize available incentives and financing for renewable energy to public agencies.
Publicize available incentives and financial facilities for renewable energy and energy storage technologies that public agencies, such as local governments and school districts, are eligible to receive. Maintain an up-to-date-list of resources from state and federal local governments on the municipal website.
[F3] Publicize existing financing programs and innovative financing models, such as third party financing, for renewable energy projects.
Publicizes existing financing programs and financing models for renewable energy projects.
HERO provides a financing opportunity for renewable projects for Fresno residents. https://www.heroprogram.com/ca/Fresno/Products. Other financing programs include: PACE program, Synergy Companies, PG&E OBF Program, and others provided by Fresno's EDC.
[F4] Ensure that renewable energy and energy storage systems are eligible in local Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) program.
Renewable energy and energy storage systems are eligible in local PACE program.
In January 2011, the City Council unanimously approved the adoption of the PACE program administered by figtreecompany.com for the City of Fresno http://www.figtreefinancing.com/commercial-pace-products/
5 of 6 Goals In Progress
1 of 6 Goals Achieved
[M1] Provide renewable energy educational resources and evaluation tools to the community.
Does not provide renewable energy educational resources and evaluation tools to the community.
Local governments can increase community awareness of clean energy technologies and local efforts related to their adoption by providing educational resources and information about financial incentives in an easy-to-access sustainability page on the municipal website.
[M2] Adopt a local sales tax exemption or property tax exemption for renewable energy systems and energy storage systems.
Has not adopted a local tax exemption for renewable energy systems and energy storage systems.
Explore the feasibility of enacting property tax and sales tax exemptions for renewable energy and energy storage systems that are that are sold to and installed on properties within the jurisdiction.
[M3] Support the organization of a community-based bulk purchase program for renewable energy systems.
City has supported a community-based bulk purchase program for renewable energy systems by hosting workshop on solar collaborative purchasing with regional participants.
[M4] Assess municipal building portfolio for renewable energy project development opportunities.
Has not assessed municipal buildings for renewable energy project development opportunities.
Convene stakeholders from planning, public works, and other relevant departments to survey the municipal facility portfolio and identify viable renewable energy project opportunities based on technical feasibility, costs, and financing options. Sites to survey include building rooftops, parking lots and car ports, open spaces, landfills, as well as wastewater treatment facilities.
[M5] Explore public-private partnerships to install renewable energy systems at affordable housing developments.
Has not explored partnerships to install renewable energy at affordable housing developments.
Convene stakeholders from relevant local agencies to survey the public housing building portfolio and identify viable renewable energy project opportunities based on technical feasibility, costs, and financing options. Explore public-private partnerships, such as third-party financing arrangements, in order to avoid upfront costs.
[M6] Explore constructing a renewable energy system at a landfill or wastewater treatment facility.
Has not explored the potential for renewable energy at a landfill or wastewater treatment facility.
City has engaged industry experts to start an initial assessment of several closed landfills for solar development.
Convene a working group of stakeholders, such as waste waster agencies, landfill operators, and community leaders to evaluate the potential for a waste-to-energy program that utilizes organic waste streams.
1 of 3 Goals In Progress
2 of 3 Goals Achieved
[WFD1] Publicize renewable energy trainings and professional development resources to local community of contractors & technicians.
Publicizes renewable energy trainings for local professional development resources.
City of Fresno is part of the Fresno Energy Watch program, which has promoted No-Cost Energy Code Training, Title 24, to examiners, engineers, inspectors, fire departments, energy consultants, real-estate agents, electricians and installers.
[WFD2] Partner with local colleges and neighboring cities/counties to promote renewable energy-focused educational programs.
Has not partnered with local organizations to promote renewable energy-focused education.
Partner with local colleges, academic, industry, utility, and workforce development organizations to support the development of certifications and specialized programs related to renewable energy technologies. Publicize renewable energy programs to the community via mailings and outreach to local high schools. Encourage colleges to host campus visit days.
[WFD3] Promote green business incentives and assistance programs to local businesses and organizations.
Promotes green business programs or resources to local community.
Fresno Energy Watch provides information on free energy assessments, benchmarks, financing programs and rebates for energy upgrades. The energy assessments reports, provided by the BETU Programs, lists energy programs which can help businesses.
TRANSPORTATION & LAND USE
|Transportation is critical to the movement of people and goods, as well as providing access to services. However, the transportation sector constitutes one of the primary end-uses of energy in communities across the country. Finding creative ways to reduce vehicle miles traveled (VMT) is proving to be a significant challenge, but also fosters an environment for new innovative solutions. By decreasing the environmental impact of their transportation systems cities can improve regional air quality and reduce their carbon footprint.|
2 of 2 Goals In Progress
[POL1] Adopt a fleet purchasing policy to replace existing municipal fleet vehicles with low-emission vehicles.
Has not adopted a low-emission vehicle fleet purchasing policy.
Adopt an ordinance or energy action plan to revise municipal fleet purchasing policies with criteria and purchasing specifications that include demonstrated emissions reductions, and analyze the costs and benefits of low-emissions vehicles and their fuel sources. Convene a working group to update municipal fleet purchasing policies and guidelines to specify vehicle emission and fuel source criteria in city/ county purchasing decisions.
[POL2] Adopt a commuter benefits ordinance and/or telecommuting policy for municipal employees.
Has not adopted a commuter benefits ordinance or telecommuting policy for municipal employees.
Evaluate feasible commuter benefits for municipal employees, such as telecommuting, flexible workweeks, and subsidies for rideshares and pubic transit. Enact an ordinance for municipal employees and promote voluntary participation amongst local businesses through highlighting the benefits of such policies and providing them with implementation resources.
1 of 1 Goals In Progress
[P1] Adopt a standardized permitting application form for electric vehicle charging stations for individually zoned end-uses.
No standard permitting form or procedure for EV charging stations for individually zoned end-uses.
Adopt a standard permit application for electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE) at AC Levels 1 and 2 (120V and 208/240V, respectively). Application should include a plot plan, an electrical load worksheet, as well as manufacturer information for the unit.
Planning & Zoning
2 of 5 Goals In Progress
3 of 5 Goals Achieved
[Z1] Integrate transportation-related smart growth goals and strategies into long-term planning documents, such as General Plans.
Has integrated transportation-related smart growth strategies into long-term planning docs.
The Smart Growth principles have been integrated into the General Plan. Principal 8: Provide a variety of transportation choices.
[Z2] Update local building and zoning codes to require electric vehicle charging station prewiring in new construction and major retrofits.
Does not require EV charging station prewiring in new construction and major retrofits.
Evaluate costs and benefits with home builders and contractors to demonstrate economic feasibility of pre-wiring requirements. Adopt local ordinance amending the California Green Building Code to include specifications for electric service requirements for electric vehicle supply equipment as well as installation recommendations for various building types. Update zoning codes and parking codes to increase access to EV chargers, establish reasonable restrictions or incentives for their use in qualifying areas, and ensure that publicly available electric vehicle charging infrastructure meets federal and state accessibility provisions.
[Z3] Incorporate adequate infrastructure to provide safe and efficient pedestrian and bicycle transit opportunities.
Has explored development of infrastructure for safe, efficient pedestrian and bicycle transit.
City of Fresno has adopted the Complete Streets concept into the General Plan. Complete Streets provides safety for a multi-modal transportation system, minimizing car travel and encourage other modes of transportation.
[Z4] Ensure that community members, including low-income residents, have close access to public transportation.
Has not ensured that all community members have close access to public transportation.
Establish and promote safe, accessible public transit hubs in residential and commercial areas. Work with local public transportation agencies, transportation planners, and community groups to determine new transit stops and routes. Publicize income-qualified reduced fare where available.
[Z5] Update zoning code to encourage transit-oriented development and urban infill.
Has updated zoning code to encourage transit-oriented development and urban infill.
Infill Development can be found in the General Plan, Chpater Three, Section Three. Transit-oriented development has been incorporated in different future projects, listed in the General Plan.
2 of 2 Goals In Progress
[F1] Promote financial incentives to increase government and private purchases of electric and alternative fuel vehicles.
Does not promote financial incentives related to the purchase of EV/alternative fuel vehicles.
Promote federal, state, and utility tax credits and/or rebates for electric and alternative fuel vehicles for Valley governments, residents, and businesses. Engage with a regional entity, such as the Air District, to offer a Valley-wide incentive program to support long-term regional and state air-quality goals.
[F2] Ensure electric vehicle charging stations are eligible under local Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) program.
Electric vehicle charging stations are not eligible under local PACE program.
Explore implementing or joining a residential or commercial Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) financing program, where allowed. Work with PACE program providers to ensure that electric vehicle charging station installations are an eligible energy upgrade measure. Evaluate PACE financing program best practices demonstrated by other communities across the country.
3 of 3 Goals In Progress
[M1] Encourage local retailers and employers to install electric vehicle charging stations for customers and employees.
Does not encourage private sector installation of EV charging stations for customers or employees.
Explore the creation of an incentive program for employers to install electric vehicle charging stations for the public and their employees. Publicize the benefits of workplace charging stations via community outreach campaigns that highlight employers and business that have installed chargers. Start with the San Joaquin Valley's Plug-In Electric Vehicle Readiness Plan and Optimal Siting Locations report.
[M2] Organize a regional initiative for government fleets to procure low-emitting vehicles as well as fuels and charging stations.
No regional initiative in place for low-emitting transportation options for government fleets.
Convene a task force of local governments and agency procurement officials across the region to evaluate the feasibility of increasing purchasing power through a formal procurement collaborative for fleet vehicles and/or equipment. Leverage available transportation expertise (through municipal shared services approach or other channels), where feasible.
[M3] Establish and publicize incentives that encourage transit-oriented development.
Has not established or publicized incentives that encourage transit-oriented development.
Publicize policy-based incentives and existing funding sources for transit-oriented development (TOD) projects, such as those that increase the amount of affordable housing in proximity to transit hubs. Determine feasible measures that the city or town can take to encourage TOD, such as density bonuses or property tax abatements.
2 of 2 Goals In Progress
[WFD1] Publicize electric/alternative fuel vehicle training and professional development resources to local workforce.
Does not publicize electric/alternative fuel vehicle training and professional development resources
Partner with regional utilities, academic and workforce development organizations to combine existing training courses with emerging new energy storage and electric vehicle-related training. Publicize trainings and educational resources related to electric vehicles and EVSE installations through various community outreach channels.
[WFD2] Partner with local colleges and neighboring communities to promote alternative vehicle education programs or technical courses.
Has not partnered with local colleges to promote alternative vehicle education programs or courses.
Inventory existing community colleges, work with local Workforce Investment Boards (WIBs) to align new training programs with expected growth in the clean energy fields. Work with State WIB to insert clean energy workforce goals into new State plans required by the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA).
|Social equity is a crucial component of sustainable development. The Sustainable Energy Roadmap aims to develop smart energy and sustainable development policies and programs at the local level that reflect the needs and priorities of target communities, reduce its businesses’ and residents’ energy prices and environmental impacts, improve the economy and generate new jobs.|
5 of 5 Goals In Progress
[POL1] Encourage local employment and job creation through municipal contracting.
Does not utilize municipal contracting measures to support local employment and job creation.
Establish a policy that encourages hiring local residents for work performed under municipal contracts. Policy can establish a minimum total percentage of work hours to be performed by local residents according to the type of contract.
[POL2] Promote participatory planning and environmental justice community inclusion in the policy-making process.
Does not promote participatory planning, including EJ community, in the policy-making process.
Incorporate environmental justice community (EJC) considerations within municipal planning updates and in setting new policies by conducting outreach, hosting community forums, and potentially establishing a planning sub-committee. Establish lasting partnerships with key stakeholders that represent interests of EJCs.
[POL3] Adopt measures to protect and improve local air quality.
Has not adopted measures to protect and improve local air quality.
Determine and work towards adoption of feasible and effective air quality measures that can be taken by a local government, such as ordinances to reduce idling by passenger vehicles, commuter benefits policies that support low-emission forms of travel, and local woodburning regulations.
[POL4] Ensure public has access to data regarding the presence of environmental hazards as well as channels for emergency notification.
Does not offer data or channels to give the public access to information on environmental hazards.
Publicize environmental data related to water, air quality, hazardous waste, and other environmental impacts and emergencies collected by local and state agencies on the municipal website. Track key indicators of environmental health and summarize on an annual basis, if possible. Utilize environmental justice community stakeholder communication channels to share information with hard-to-reach community members, particularly in the case of an environmental emergency.
[POL5] Ensure compliance and enforcement of federal, state, and local environmental and air quality regulations.
Does not ensure compliance and enforcement of federal, state, and local environmental regulations.
Promote easy-to-access channels for the community to report environmental infractions, such as a link to the CalEPA reporting form, and publicize in multiple languages and culturally-sensitive ways. Promote sector-specific compliance resources to local industries that may be subject to environmental regulations, such as the EPA's Compliance Assistance Centers.
Planning & Zoning
2 of 2 Goals In Progress
[Z1] Update zoning codes to provide for access to green spaces in all areas of the community.
Zoning code does not address access to green spaces for disadvantaged communities.
Where safe and feasible, convert empty lots, brownfields, and other spaces in existing neighborhoods to parks and publicly accessible open space. Require green space in new residential developments to appropriately minimize the impact of human development as well as provide a livable environment for residents. Expand urban tree canopy with drought-resistant trees where possible.
[Z2] Update zoning and permitting standards to restrict highly polluting facilities in proximity to residential areas and water resources.
Has not updated codes to restrict proximity of highly polluting facilities to certain areas.
Zoning for new projects requiring special use and/or environmental permits should consider proximity to residential areas and establish limits for the size and quantity of polluting facilities in an single area.
1 of 1 Goals In Progress
[F1] Promote clean energy financing and utility assistance programs that are accessible to all community members.
Does not promote clean energy and utility assistance programs to disadvantaged communities.
Document and promote clean energy and alternative transportation resources, including rebates and incentives, financing options, and utility assistance programs. Provide for disadvantaged community education and access to low- or no-cost resources in language and culturally-sensitive ways. Consider participating in a working group to identify gaps within and across existing programs.
2 of 2 Goals In Progress
[M1] Ensure all community members receive clean energy policy and program information through culturally-sensitive channels.
Has not ensured disadvantaged communities get latest clean energy info through appropriate channels.
Provide for translated versions of materials on new clean energy and sustainable development programs and resources, tailored to the most common non-English languages spoken in your community. Leverage appropriate community channels and stakeholders to disseminate this information.
[M2] Ensure all community members have access to emergency weather shelters.
Has not ensured that disadvantaged communities have access to emergency weather shelters.
Locate and publicize cooling centers as well as warming centers within Environmental Justice Community areas during extreme weather events. Provide access to affordable potable water at these centers in the case of an extreme water shortage.
1 of 1 Goals In Progress
[WFD1] Foster and promote local and regional green job training and placement pathways.
Does not promote local and regional green job training and placement pathways.
Develop partnerships with and foster connections between area green industry, workforce training, and placement stakeholders. Promote programs and resources to disadvantaged communities in culturally and language-appropriate ways.